Last year I used 99designs to get a logo for my new startup Percollate. I was pretty pleased with it. Apart from fridge-drawings by my kids I’d never had anything designed for me before and it was exciting. Back then I had no idea of the kind of fallout this would create in my local community. I had genuinely never considered that this approach could be viewed negatively by people. After all, it’s got a kind of crowd-sourced feel to it so it has to be good. Right?
Turns out that most designers are dead against sites that take this approach. I say ‘most’ because these site exist and seem to be profitable. Most of these people I see regularly, respect the opinions of and certainly don’t want to upset. To get an understanding of their arguments check out http://antispec.com/.
A few weeks ago I enlisted 99designs for a second time to help me with a logo for Awedience. Clearly, I hadn’t forgotten what happened last time so why did I do it?
One of the suggested alternatives a year ago was to engage my local community. Actually, I like this idea. At the start of the year I embarked on a web-based side project and decided that I didn’t want to be involved with the design / UI side of things. To a packed audience I announced the project and explicitly asked for people to come join me and build it. I had dozens of conversations about how exciting the idea was but not a single offer of design interest. Not one. So, as time was of the essence, I got on with it myself.
Design is Subjective
Most people will agree that Wagner was a genius. Fewer people, however, will find his work to their taste. It’s subjective. Getting into a relationship with a designer really worries me because our tastes might simply be misaligned. Having to terminate a contract after weeks of work would be devastating. 99designs is a great way to quickly find someone that seems to share your particular, personal, subjective tastes.
99designs has Changed
99designs allows you to throw your net to the whole community at the start of a competition. However, within just a few days you have to pick a handful of finalists. I appreciate that this argument will not hold much water for many people reading this but it does mean that those unlikely to win find out quickly.
Awedience is Multi-sourced
The logo came from 99designs. The theme was bought from ThemeForest and tweaked by one of my advisers. For my part, I have be putting in 12 hour days for some considerable time building the application frontend and associated cloud services. The point I’m making is that I have considered the startup as a whole and thought carefully about how best a build each individual part.
We ALL do Spec Work
Nobody wants to work for free. However, unless you work 9-5 and are never called upon to speculate or take a risk, at some point, you’ve done spec work. I can only speak for my own industry and experience, but here are two concrete examples…
Tenders for Technical Contracts
At my previous company we built a business offering platforms to various financial and government bodies. At no point were we able to simply show our previous work and get handed a contract. Here’s how we would spend the man-months:
- Understanding the client’s requirements
- Infrastructure design
- Integration understanding and design
- Failure identification and problem solving
- Cost analysis
- Pre-Pitch documentation
- Presentation creation
- Presentation planning
- Presentation practice
- Travel to client offices
Technical Job Inteviews
- Spend time writing a CV
- Spend time searching for a position
- Attend first interview – do we like you and is your shit together (at least on paper)?
- Attend second interview where you’ll sit our tests and actually show us what you know. (Some companies I know also expect you to deliver a formal presentation of your work).
Cost / Benefit Analysis
I do not hold with the argument that designers are being treated differently to the rest of the world. Companies like 99designs have come into an established industry and disrupted it. Telling everyone not to use these new services will not work. Designers and design companies either need to find a better solution to the problems raised in this post or concede the ground.
Finally, I believe in open, constructive discussions. Apart from spam, I won’t delete any comments from this post.